Mar. 9, 2025 | by AIS Toscana
ECCELLENZE DI TOSCANA 2025
94.5/100 | PIANTONAIA 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
93.5/100 | IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
91/100 | CAPOGATTO 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
86/100 | POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
85/100 | CHIARA AURORA 2022 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
Feb. 10, 2025 | by Ella Lister & Martin Lemaire
LE FIGARO “ET VOUSE”
In the Special Edition of the French daily newspaper Le Figaro, in conjunction with the “Wine Paris” fair, a tasting is dedicated to Italian wines.
94/100 | #10/40 | IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“A deep and complex nose, with notes of orange peel, but also fresh cherry. Very pure in the mouth, with a caressing sweetness and floral aromas of violet, then come menthol, eucalyptus, and finally a little black fruit. Very smooth overall”
Nov. 16, 2024 | by Tamlyn Currin
JANCISROBINSON.COM
⇒ Podere Poggio Scalette on Jancisrobinson.com ⇐
Subscribers only
17.5/20 | PIANTONAIA 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Intense, red-slash, scarlet and anise. Wonderfully vibrant, alive with flashes of Aranciata sweet bitterness and orange-peel fragrance. Grilled orange. A very exciting wine with tremendous energy and vertical and intention. Elegant but also a little fierce”
17/20 | IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Sometimes I just want to write, ‘I like this wine’. Like this wine. It’s quite oaky, but it’s somehow getting away with it because the fruit (which tastes one minute like black cherries and the next like blackberries) is so plump and juicy. It’s oozing exuberance. Ripe fruit smudged with chocolate and a dusting of cocoa. And then the tannins sweep in like autumn, bringing a smoky soft crackle of leafiness”
17/20 | CAPOGATTO 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Concentrated but poised. Dark and deep with ripe, tangy damsons. Like all these Poggio Scalette wines, the fruit is shining with generosity and integrity; fluent; effortlessly rich without being jammy, intense without being worked or extracted. The tannins are equally effortless, looping through the fruit with cursive ease. Graceful, complete and delicious”
16.5/20 | POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
“Is this exactly what Chianti Classico should taste like? I can’t help thinking yes. Sour cherry, damsons, fruit that is etched with hot-road-stones minerality and bay-leaf bitterness but also sweet and also cooked and also fresh. The tannins feel like satin ribbons dipped in ink and dragged through the dust of old pencil shavings. And on the finish, I can taste thyme and iron. Tenderness and tang”
16/20 | CHIARA AURORA 2022 IGT Alta Valle della Greve bianco
“An attractive nose of hay and forsythia flowers. Bright yellow with ripe fruit and flowers and a zesty wreath of acidity and bitterness. Lots of sweet-and-sharp citrus. Citron, grapefruit, Cape gooseberry, tarragon, five spice. Good balance. Appetising”
Nov. 16, 2024 | by Bibenda Fondazione Italiana Sommelier
BIBENDA 2025
IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
CAPOGATTO 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
PIANTONAIA 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
CHIARA AURORA 2022 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
Nov. 12, 2024 | by SEMINARIO PERMANENTE LUIGI VERONELLI Editore
I VINI DI VERONELLI GUIDA ORO 2025
95/100 | IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
94/100 | PIANTONAIA 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
93/100 | CAPOGATTO 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
90/100 | POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
89/100 | CHIARA AURORA 2022 IGT Alta Valle della Greve bianco
Oct. 16, 2024 | by Othmar Kiem, Simon Staffler
Falstaff | Wine Magazine
FALSTAFF WINE GUIDE ITALY 2025
⇒ Podere Poggio Scalette on Falstaff ⇐
94/100 | PIANTONAIA 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Bright, very dense ruby with purple elements. Open nose with black cherry, light blackcurrant, later plum confit, with some undergrowth behind it. Elegant palate, taut acidity with firm tannins. Good palate drive, slightly drying. Dancing, balanced finish”
93/100 | IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Bright, very dense ruby with purple elements. Delicate, somewhat closed bouquet of coriander seeds and some allspice, followed by black cherry and cocoa. Tight, restrained palate with a slight draw, fruity. Retronasal some sour cherry. Opens up later with a juicy mouthfeel and a medium-long finish”
93/100 | CAPOGATTO 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Bright, dense ruby with shine. The nose is richly savoury with pepper and subtle vanilla, followed by sour cherry and sweet blood orange, later mocha. Opens softly on the palate, with bright fruit, well-integrated tannins, medium palate drive with some restraint and slight bitterness on the finish”
90/100 | POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
“Deep ruby red. Inviting aroma of plum and redcurrant paired with savouriness. Fresh and mineral on the palate, grippy tannins, medium finish”
90/100 | CHIARA AURORA 2022 IGT Alta Valle della Greve bianco
“Bright, shiny straw yellow with a golden core. Initially somewhat closed on the nose, ripe stone fruit notes, citrus fruit and balsamic notes. Straightforward on the palate, mouthwatering, refreshing acidity, salty finish, medium length”
Oct. 14, 2024 | by Daniele Cernilli
THE DOCTOR WINE
From: “Guida Essenziale ai Vini d’Italia 2025“
Sept. 18, 2024 | by Sarah Heller MW
CLUBOENOLOGIQUE.COM
From: “The Chianti Classico Report 2024“
“Poggio Scalette is one of the star players in the much-admired area of Ruffoli in southern Greve, known for its macigno (sandstone) geology and high ridges. The terraced vineyards here average an altitude of 450m (1,475ft), with some reaching nearly 600m (1,970ft) – conditions that somewhat resemble the renowned high-altitude UGA of Lamole, from which the Sangiovese vine material here derives. There is a strong push-pull between ripeness – coming from warmer soils and exposures (west/southwest) – and freshness from altitude. The nose is dark but markedly herbal, with citronella, verbena and oregano over relatively muted dark mulberry fruit. Very dark-fruited and sapid on the entry, it has incandescent acidity that comes blazing through its opaque, compact mid-palate. However, the tannins remain gruff, having aged exclusively in lined concrete tanks, and this clearly needs more time to open up”
Sept. 13/, 2024 | by Raffaela Vecchione
WINECRITIC.COM
97/100 | IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Slender and decidedly clear in the sensory profile, it shows notes of lavender, wild violet, black pepper, juniper berries and marjoram. In the background, Mediterranean citrus fruits describe the main scene of great charm and territorial character. Medium-full body, soft tannins of very fine grain and a graceful and tasty finish that is enhanced from the center of the palate onwards. Infinite in beauty and personality. Drink now or age”
97/100 | PIANTONAIA 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Black plums, blackberries, sandalwood, incense, juniper berries and coriander are the main scents of Piantonaia 2021 which reaches a degree of authority and superior spiciness. Full body, soft tannins and a finish of impressive taste beauty where everything is in the right place. It is agile, savory, slender, tasty. What a beautiful expression, one of the best ever! Drink now or age”
93/100 | CAPOGATTO 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Bright and essential, it shows notes of geraniums, plums, licorice, magnolias, walnuts, elderflowers and peppermint. Medium-full body, smooth and relaxed in the sip, it closes with great agility and harmony. Drink now“
89/100 | POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
“Very ripe on the nose, it shows notes of dried red plums, citron pieces and sweet white flowers. Medium body, slightly marked tannins and a simple finish. Drink now“
Jul. 31, 2024 | by Touring Club Italiano Editore
VINIBUONI D’ITALIA 2025
| IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
| POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
Jul. 25, 2024 | by Monica Larner
ROBERTPARKER.COM
From: “Tuscany, Chianti Classico:Follow My Lead“
93/100 | IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“From a classic vintage, the Poggio Scalette 2021 Il Carbonaione is a rich and darkly colored expression of Sangiovese with black ruby hues. There is more color saturation here than you would find in most Sangiovese-based wines, and this bottle could be matched to heftier foods featuring red or game meats. The wine holds to the palate with intensity and imparts solid and lasting fruit weight. The Fiore family has crafted a pretty IGT wine”
87/100 | CHIANTI CLASSICO 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
“In the bottle with the red capsule, the Poggio Scalette 2022 Chianti Classico has a hint of extra-ripe fruit that comes off as cooked cherry or raspberry jam. The wine is soft and quite simple all said and done. That easy ripeness hooks into a one-dimensional mouthfeel with a hint of bitterness to close. I took a few points off because of that sticky ripeness. This is your simple weeknight spaghetti and red sauce choice”
Jul. 11, 2024 | by Antonio Galloni
VINOUS
From: “Chianti Classico: The Magnificient 2021s“
96/100 | PIANTONAIA 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“The 2021 Piantonaia, the estate’s pure Merlot, is superb. In fact, the 2021 might be the best edition I have tasted. A rush of dark red/purplish fruit, blood orange, pomegranate and spice saturates the palate, lifted by bright acids that lend energy. I admire the wine’s depth, textural intensity and overall balance. The only real question is why all vintages aren’t more like this”
95+/100 | IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“The 2021 Il Carbonaione is a regal, elegant wine. Silky, beautifully perfumed and persistent, the 2021 is everything I want from Il Carbonaione. All the purity of Sangiovese caresses the senses in a wine that is both textually intense and also light on its feet. Dark red-toned fruit, rose petals, cinnamon, new leather and cedar are some of the many nuances that open in the glass. Silky, polished tannins wrap it all together in style. I would give this a few years in bottle, or a healthy decant if that is not possible”
95/100 | CAPOGATTO 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“The 2021 Capogatto is terrific. Dark, vibrant and super-expressive, the 2021 shows all the energy of the year. Bright saline notes cut through a core of super-ripe blue/purplish fruit, lavender, sage, mint and mocha. All the elements are so well put together in this deep, racy Merlot blend”
90/100 | CHIANTI CLASSICO 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
“The 2022 Chianti Classico is a racy, opulent wine. Ripe black cherry, spice, leather, tobacco and mocha fill out the layers in this deep, resonant Chianti Classico. There’s a fair bit of tannin, so another year or so in bottle will only help. This is a fine effort from Poggio Scalette that gains freshness with air”
Jun. 18-19, 2024 | by James Suckling
JamesSuckling.com
95/100 | IL CARBONAIONE 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Complex and attractive aromas of blueberries, cedar, cinnamon stick and potpourri, following through to a full-bodied, concentrated palate with a firm yet velvety tannin frame. Long, deep and focused. A wonderfully perfumed and polished expression of sangiovese. Best after 2025”
93/100 | PIANTONAIA 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“A fleshy, dark-fruited and perfumed red that has aromas and flavors of walnuts, blueberries, lavender and mocha. It’s full-bodied, creamy and plush. Rich and concentrated, but not heavy. Merlot. Drink or hold”
93/100 | CAPOGATTO 2021 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“This has an array of baked blueberries, cassis, currants, paprika and violets on the nose. Ripe yet tangy on the full-bodied palate with berry-soaked tannins and a long, plush and fruity finish. Drinkable already, but better from 2025”
91/100 | POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
“This has plum, orange peel and tobacco on the nose, alongside some sun-dried tomato. It’s savory, juicy and fresh on the palate with medium body and sleek tannins. Delicious now”
92/100 | CHIARA AURORA 2022 IGT Alta Valle della Greve bianco
“Attractive aromas of chalky lemons, orange blossoms, savory herbs and hints of ripe guava and crushed stones. Medium-bodied, juicy and vivid on the palate, with delicious fruit and subtle mineral nuances at the end. Drink or hold”
June 3, 2024 | by Michaela Morris (at Consorzio Vino Chianti Classico , 15 Feb 2024)
DECANTER
From the published article “Chianti Classico Annata: New releases in 2024”
91/100 | POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
Rising steeply from 350 to 550 metres above sea level, Poggio Scalette’s stone-terraced vineyards sit in the upper, arid reaches of the Greve Valley. Matured in concrete rather than wood, the annata gives a keen sense of place through its pure fruit expression. It is attractively scented with thyme and sage blossoms emerging from warm, dusty earth, and there’s an ease and joyfulness to the red-berried palate without being oversimplified. The tannins are lightly chalky, and tangy acidity stimulates the appetite
May 19, 2024 | by Marcus Hofshuster
Wein.Plus
88/100 | POGGIO SCALETTE 2022 DOCG Chianti Classico
Somewhat herbaceous nose, predominantly blue berries and cherries with tobacco and dried meaty notes. Tart, dark fruit, relatively present, yet fine tannins, noticeable bite, certain persistence, still undeveloped, herbal and tobacco nuances, hints of smoke, some salt, a hint of coffee grounds, very good, tart finish. Should mature a little more.
Translated from German via Google Translate
Feb. 23, 2024 | by Ian D’Agata
TERROIR SENSE WINE REVIEW
“FROM THE ARCHIVES, ICONIC ITALIAN WINES: A FANTASTIC TASTING IN LONDON”
93/100 | IL CARBONAIONE 2010 IGT Alta Valle della Greve
“Very deep ruby-red. Aromas and flavours of red and dark cherry and potpourri, with strong presence of tobacco and medicinal herbs. The finish is long and boasts earthy, herbal and tarry nuances. Mouthcoating but relatively smooth, this is drinking beautifully now but has the stuffing to age further. It is an atypical Sangiovese wine, made with what is thought to be a specific biotype of Sangiovese of Lamole that can grow and ripen in that cooler climate environment giving bigger fleshier wines than Sangiovese. For sure, the Carbonaione sub-subarea has always been thought of very highly; in fact, records indicate it was the first of a then barren area to be replanted after World War I. Drinking window: 2024-2032”
Jan. 25, 2024 | by Tony Wood
Tony Wood Italian Wine
“CHIANTI CLASSICO COLLECTION 2024”
96/100 | POGGIO DCALETTE 2021 DOCG Chianti Classico
“Deep ruby red in colour. Aromatics of violet, hyacinth, lavender and humus. Blackberry, blackcurrant, damson, plum, boysenberry and liquorice. Wild and savoury. Saline infused energy. Crushed rock minerality. Floats on the palate. Finely grained tannins with fresh acidity, drive the energy. Captivating. A puff of white smoke on the close. A stellar indulgence!”